diff --git a/exec/SlyEdit_IceStuff.js b/exec/SlyEdit_IceStuff.js
index f931e1bd069cd0f6661f0a6611a89fda18433d06..ef489d6a9ccfd37c78d757eba927a7c3b75b5e91 100644
--- a/exec/SlyEdit_IceStuff.js
+++ b/exec/SlyEdit_IceStuff.js
@@ -48,12 +48,11 @@ function readColorConfig(pFilename)
 		var colorSettingsObj = themeFile.iniGetObject();
 		themeFile.close();
 
-		// Make a backup of the menuOptClassicColors setting so we can set it
-		// back in the Ice color settings object after setting the colors.
-		var useClassicColorsBackup = gConfigSettings.iceColors.menuOptClassicColors;
 		// Ice-specific colors
 		for (var prop in gConfigSettings.iceColors)
 		{
+			if (prop == "menuOptClassicColors") // Skip this one (it's a boolean value, not a color)
+				continue;
 			if (colorSettingsObj.hasOwnProperty(prop))
 			{
 				// Using toString() to ensure the color attributes are strings (in case the value is just a number)
@@ -76,8 +75,6 @@ function readColorConfig(pFilename)
 				gConfigSettings.genColors[prop] = attrCodeStr(value);
 			}
 		}
-
-		gConfigSettings.iceColors.menuOptClassicColors = useClassicColorsBackup;
 	}
 }