Skip to content

NNTP: FTN addresses in (From) Display names

The NNTP server renders the From field of FTN messages like this:

"John Doe" (1:2/3) <John.Doe@f3.n2.z1.fidonet>

Some newsreaders show that as John Doe (1:2/3), others as John Doe, and there's one that does John Doe" (1:2/3)

I think that the correct way to render it, according to the RFCs, should be:

"John Doe (1:2/3)" <John.Doe@f3.n2.z1.fidonet>

It's an easy fix - just change line 36 in newsutil.js to:

		return format("\"%s (%s)\" <%s>"

But... is it necessary to have the FTN address in the From field? If not, I suggest it is changed to only display the name, like: "John Doe" <John.Doe@f3.n2.z1.fidonet>

(This would require changing the line above to return format("\"%s\" <%s>", but also remove the second parameter)

Would this break anything?

PS this also happens with QWK addresses (though I've not tested)